The evolutionary roots of cuckolding lie beneath all the spreadsheets, Starbucks orders, and swiping through dating apps, we’re still basically animals. Yep, you—sitting there in your comfy modern life sipping your chai latte—have a brain that’s been evolving for 400,000 years. That’s way longer than the 10,000 years of so-called “civilized” society. The evolutionary roots of cuckolding, our primal, tribal instincts are still running the show, even if we like to pretend otherwise. This is bot a follow-up and a different take on a blog that I wrote a few months ago about cuckolding being an adaptation of human mating practices.
One juicy example of the way our mating practices have adapted to our highly social and tribal roots is cuckolding. Yeah, that thing where a guy gets turned on by his partner being with someone else. Perhaps even a sense of pride that the alpha wanted to take a turn with his partner. It might seem wild or “out there” at first glance, but when you peel back the layers of modern life, you’ll see it’s not so strange after all. In fact, it might just be a throwback to how humans operated for hundreds of thousands of years. Let’s dive into the animalistic side of things—because let’s face it, that’s where the fun is!
Picture life in a prehistoric tribe: no TikTok, no HR departments, just raw survival. Tribes had a hierarchy, plain and simple. At the top was the alpha male—the guy who called the shots, protected the group, and, most importantly, got first dibs on all the women. This wasn’t about being romantic; it was about spreading his strong genes far and wide.
And what about the other guys? Well, they had a choice: challenge the alpha (and risk getting eaten by a saber-tooth tiger), or find a way to stay in the tribe and survive. Submitting to the alpha wasn’t weak—it was smart. It kept them alive, gave them access to the group’s resources, and even mate with the women of the tribe when the alpha didn't want them.
Fast forward to today, and those ancient survival strategies are still baked into our brains. That little voice in the back of a cuckold’s head—the one that says, "It’s okay to let her enjoy someone else"—is really just your lizard brain saying, "Stay in the tribe. Survival first."
Studies on human mating strategies back this up. Research shows that men’s sexual jealousy varies widely depending on context. In some situations, men experience arousal instead of jealousy when their partner is with someone else—likely because it triggers deep, subconscious cues about their role in a larger hierarchy. This is more common than you might think, and evolutionary psychologists argue it stems from our tribal past.…
“By yielding to a more dominant male (the “bull”), the cuckold unconsciously activates the part of his brain that evolved to accept hierarchical submission as a means of staying within the tribe. This submission is not weakness—it’s an instinctive acknowledgment of a role within a system, which brings a strange sense of security and belonging.”
It took me many years to come to terms with this reality. Fighting it is a loosing battle. Too much energy protecting the facade of monogamy. We like to think modern civilization has overcome this, and it has on the surface, but the innate behaviors still run under the shell of polite society. Liberating and unleashing female sexuality has allowed males to experience this level of sexual liberation. Men are very good at sorting out hierarchies in work and social settings. I would suggest humility instead of humiliation is the spice and reward for a husband to let go of his possessiveness.
.”At its core, cuckolding reinforces an ancient mate hierarchy, with the woman as the center of control and desire. By engaging with a “bull,” the woman asserts her ability to select the strongest, most desirable mate while signaling her sexual autonomy. This taps into an evolutionary drive to secure the best possible genetic material while maintaining control over her own choices. The act of humiliation further amplifies this dynamic, as it places the woman in a position of superiority, reaffirming her dominance within the relationship.”
May I suggest that not all pre-history societies were an “all or nothing” experience for less dominant males. That actually comes later with agriculture and City States. In them, a small portion of the male population actually had offspring. However, because we don’t exist in small tribes, we have modified the modern cuckolding experience to amplify both female centric power and male submission making it a bit more portable.
A wonderful recap of the advantage of this approach to contemporary relationships is best expressed in this part of the essay by Emma;
“On a psychological level, the cuckold’s arousal is also tied to the relinquishing of control. In modern life, men are often expected to maintain dominance, make decisions, and carry societal pressures. Submitting in the bedroom allows the lizard brain to let go of those expectations and indulge in primal, raw emotions. The euphoria comes from fully embracing this dynamic and experiencing arousal in a way that aligns with ancient instincts, where survival and mating success weren’t just about dominance but also about cooperation and submission.”
5 stars! Accidentally rated as 4.5
5